Beneficial owner — the 25% test and control tests
Almost everyone knows the 25% rule for identifying a beneficial owner. Far fewer notice that it is only half the definition. Under Article 51 of Regulation (EU) 2024/1624 (the AMLR), the beneficial owners of a legal entity are the natural persons who have an ownership interest or who control the entity, and the Regulation says expressly that control via other means is identified independently of and in parallel to ownership. A structure can therefore have beneficial owners who hold no shares at all. This piece walks through the ownership arithmetic, the control tests, the fallback to senior managing officials, the register cross-check, and three cases that show where onboarding files usually break.
1. Which rulebook applies, and when
The AMLR applies from 10 July 2027 (Article 90); until then, national laws transposing Directive (EU) 2015/849 govern. The two texts are close but not identical, and the gap matters for anyone designing a beneficial-ownership engine now:
| Point | Directive (EU) 2015/849 (until 9 July 2027) | AMLR, Articles 51-54 (from 10 July 2027) |
|---|---|---|
| Ownership threshold | 25% plus one share, or an ownership interest of more than 25%, as an indication of ownership | Ownership of 25% or more of shares, voting rights or other ownership interest |
| Status of the threshold | An indication, applied through national law | A definition in a directly applicable regulation |
| Indirect ownership | Left largely to national guidance | Multiply along each chain, add the chains together, count every level |
| Control via other means | Referred to, without a closed list | Minimum list in Article 53(3), open list in 53(4) |
| Lower thresholds | National gold-plating possible | Commission may set a lower threshold (maximum 15%, always below 25%) for higher-risk categories by delegated act |
The practical consequence: a natural person with exactly 25% is not caught by the “more than 25%” wording but is caught by the AMLR’s “25% or more”. Build the comparison operator as a parameter, not a hard-coded constant.
2. Ownership interest: the 25% test, and how to compute it
Article 52(1) defines an ownership interest as direct or indirect ownership of 25% or more of the shares, voting rights or other ownership interest, including rights to a share of profits, other internal resources or the liquidation balance. Two mechanics matter more than the number:
- Indirect ownership is multiplied along each chain. The holdings of intermediate entities are multiplied through, and the results from the different chains are then added together (unless Article 54 applies, see section 4).
- Every level counts. All shareholdings on every level of ownership are taken into account when assessing whether an ownership interest exists.
That is a calculation, not a lookup. A person holding 40% of an entity that holds 40% of your customer has 16% through that chain; if they also hold 15% directly, the sum is 31% and they are a beneficial owner. Note too that “ownership interest” is wider than shares: profit-participation rights and liquidation preferences count, so a person with a 30% profit entitlement and 10% of the shares is inside the definition.
For legal entities other than corporate entities, where ownership cannot sensibly be calculated, Article 52(4) points straight to control via other means. Foundations and similar entities follow the position-based list in Article 57, and express trusts the list in Article 58.
3. Control, which is the half that gets missed
Article 53 defines control of a legal entity as the possibility to exercise, directly or indirectly, significant influence and impose relevant decisions within it. It then separates three ideas that are often conflated:
| Concept | Test (Article 53) |
|---|---|
| Control through ownership interest | Direct or indirect ownership of 50% plus one of the shares, voting rights or other ownership interest |
| Indirect control | Control of intermediate entities in the structure, where direct control is identified on each level |
| Control via other means: minimum list | Majority of voting rights (including in concert); right to appoint or remove a majority of the board; relevant veto or decision rights attached to shares; decisions on profit distribution or shifts in assets |
| Control via other means: open list | Formal or informal agreements, articles, partnership or syndication agreements, voting arrangements; family relationships; formal or informal nominee arrangements |
Article 51 requires the control strand to run even when the ownership strand has already produced a name. The Regulation also defines a formal nominee arrangement (a contract under which a nominator instructs a nominee to act as director, shareholder or settlor on its behalf), and Article 22(1)(b)(iv) requires you to collect the names of persons holding shares or directorships in nominee form. A nominee shareholder is never the end of the trail; the nominator is the person you are looking for.
4. Multi-layer structures: when the multiplication stops
Article 54 covers structures where ownership and control coexist on different layers of the same chain. In that situation the beneficial owners are (a) the natural persons who control the legal entities holding a direct ownership interest in your customer, and (b) the natural persons who hold an ownership interest in an entity that controls your customer. In plain terms: once a layer is controlled (50% plus one, or control via other means), you do not keep diluting through it by multiplication. The controller of that layer is treated as standing in its shoes.
Article 55 adds the trust overlay: where a trust, or an entity similar to a trust, holds an ownership interest or control, the beneficial owners of that trust or entity become beneficial owners of your customer.
5. Worked example: the 60% holding company
Facts: A Spanish payment institution onboards OpCo S.L. HoldCo B.V. owns 60% of OpCo; an unrelated investor owns 40% directly. A natural person, Ms A, owns 45% of HoldCo; Mr B owns 55% of HoldCo.
What the rule says: Pure multiplication gives Ms A 27% (45% x 60%) and Mr B 33% (55% x 60%). But HoldCo controls OpCo through ownership interest (60% is more than 50% plus one), and Mr B controls HoldCo (55%). Because ownership and control coexist in this chain, Article 54 applies instead of plain multiplication. Under Article 54(a), the person controlling the entity with the direct holding is a beneficial owner: Mr B. Under Article 54(b), anyone with an ownership interest in the entity that controls OpCo is also a beneficial owner: Ms A, with 45% of HoldCo. The 40% direct investor, if a natural person, is a beneficial owner in their own right.
What the practitioner does: Records three beneficial owners, keeps the computation sheet (each chain, each multiplication, the sum) in the file, and flags Mr B’s basis as “control” rather than “ownership”.
Outcome: The file shows both strands were run. A reviewer can trace each name back to an article of the Regulation instead of to an analyst’s instinct.
6. Worked example: the 10% founder with the veto
Facts: A fintech customer has a dispersed cap table; no natural person reaches 25%. The shareholders’ agreement gives the founder, who holds 10%, the right to appoint three of five directors and a veto over dividend distributions.
What the rule says: The right to appoint a majority of the board is on the Article 53(3) minimum list; so are decisions on profit distribution. The founder is a beneficial owner through control via other means, whatever the shareholding.
What the practitioner does: Requests the shareholders’ agreement and articles at onboarding, not just the register extract, and records the specific clause relied on. If the register lists only “senior managing officials” because no one passes 25%, that is a discrepancy to be handled under Article 24.
Outcome: A file built from the register alone would have missed the person who actually runs the company. This is the most common gap supervisors find in corporate onboarding.
7. When nobody qualifies: the senior managing official fallback
Article 22(2) sets the fallback. Only after all possible means of identification have been exhausted, or where there are doubts that the persons identified are the real beneficial owners, does the obliged entity record that no beneficial owner was identified and identify and verify all natural persons holding senior managing official positions. Where verifying them would tip off the customer that you doubt its ownership story, you abstain from verification and record the steps taken instead. Either way, the records must show the actions taken and the difficulties met.
The fallback is a conclusion, not a default. A file that jumps to “SMO: CEO” without documenting the ownership arithmetic and the control review will not survive a supervisory sample.
8. The register is a cross-check, and discrepancies have a clock
Article 22(7) lets you verify beneficial owners through the identity-verification routes of Article 22(6) or through reasonable measures using reliable sources, including public registers other than the central registers, and then requires you to also consult the central register. Article 23(4) requires valid proof of registration, or a recently issued register excerpt, when you open a relationship with an entity subject to registration.
Under Article 24, discrepancies between your findings and the central register must be reported without undue delay and within 14 calendar days of detection, with the information showing the discrepancy and who you consider the beneficial owners to be. For typographical or transliteration differences, or outdated data where you know the true owner from another reliable source and see no concealment, you may instead ask the customer to correct the register within 14 days; if they do not, you report. That derogation is not available in higher-risk cases.
9. Worked example: the register that is a year out of date
Facts: An Italian e-money institution reviews an existing corporate customer. The central register names a former 35% shareholder who sold out a year ago; the share-transfer deed, provided by the customer, shows the stake now held by the CEO’s spouse.
What the rule says: This is outdated data, and the true owner is known from a reliable source. If there is no sign of concealment and the case is not higher risk, Article 24(2) allows the firm to invite the customer to correct the register within 14 calendar days. The family relationship is also a control indicator under Article 53(4)(b).
What the practitioner does: Sends the invitation, diarises day 14, reviews whether spouse and CEO act together, and reports to the register on day 15 if the filing has not been made.
Outcome: The register is corrected, and the file shows the decision path and the date stamps that prove the deadline was met.
FAQ
Is 25% a threshold or a starting point?
It is the definition of an ownership interest under Article 52. It is not the whole definition of a beneficial owner, because control via other means is assessed separately and can identify people below or outside the shareholding structure entirely.
Does a person with exactly 25% count?
Under the AMLR, yes: the test is 25% or more. Under the current Directive wording, the indication is more than 25% or 25% plus one share, so check your national transposition until 10 July 2027.
How is indirect ownership calculated?
Multiply the holdings along each chain of intermediate entities, then add the results from the different chains. Where a layer is controlled, Article 54 identifies the controller of that layer instead of diluting through it.
Can a beneficial owner hold no shares at all?
Yes. Board-appointment rights, veto rights, profit-distribution rights, family relationships and nominee arrangements can all make a non-shareholder a beneficial owner through control via other means.
When can we name senior managing officials instead?
Only after exhausting all possible means of identification, or where you doubt the persons identified. You record that no beneficial owner was found and identify and verify all senior managing officials.
What if the register says something different from our file?
Report the discrepancy within 14 calendar days of detection, with your evidence. For minor or outdated-data cases with no concealment risk, you may first ask the customer to correct the register within 14 days.
What to do, today
- Onboarding engineering: make the threshold and its operator (“>” or “≥”) configuration, and store the full chain computation with each case.
- KYB analysts: add a control checklist built on Article 53(3) and 53(4) and require articles and shareholders’ agreements for every corporate customer.
- MLRO: sample files that ended in a senior managing official and test whether the “all possible means” step is evidenced.
- Operations: log detection dates for register discrepancies and diarise the 14-day deadline.
- Policy owners: map the 10 July 2027 switch from national transposition to the AMLR into the CDD procedure now.
Related: Ireland — the RBO · Spain’s beneficial ownership register · Transparenzregister in Germany · The EU AML package timeline · Registre des bénéficiaires effectifs — France · UBO-register — the Netherlands · Registro dei titolari effettivi — Italy · RBE — Luxembourg · Beneficial owners of a trust — Ireland’s CRBOT


